| Archbishop Spalding | Cavaliers | A | 8 | Will Comerford '17 | | | |
| B | 3 | Jake Vickers '18 | | Noah Strother '16 | |
| Broadneck High School | Bruins | A | 1 | Jessica Bennett '15 | | Kate Selley '16 | |
| B | 2 | Phillip Schofield '17 | | Erin McElwee '15 | 1-4 |
| | Lydia McPherson '15 | 5-8 |
| Canisius High School | Varsity | A | 14 | | | | |
| B | 13 | | | | |
| Christchurch School | Seahorses | A | 5 | Brendan Little '18 | | Sally Johnson '18 | |
| B | 8 | Austen Freda '17 | | Thomas Walker '17 | |
| Donovan Catholic High School | Griffins | A | 10 | Erin McGarry '17 | | Maureen McGarry '17 | |
| B | 10 | John Degeorgis '15 | 1-4 | Alexis Tedesco '17 | |
| Margaret MacCormack '17 | 5-8 | | |
| Edmund Burke School | Varsity | A | 6 | Casey Cabot '17 | | Genevieve Dickinson '17 | 1-4,7-8 |
| | Talia Frank '17 | 5-6 |
| B | 4 | Tye Rubin '17 | | River Carson '17 | |
| Norfolk Academy | Bulldogs | A | 2 | James Whitmore '16 | | Alek Sas '18 | |
| B | 1 | Marshall McCraw '16 | | Alexander Singh '15 | |
| Rumson-Fair Haven | Bulldogs | A | 12 | Michael Munger '16 | | Marcello Sgroi '16 | 1-2 |
| | Francesco Sgroi '16 | 3-8 |
| B | 6 | Addie Sellig '16 | | Teddy Schroeder '16 | |
| Severn School | Admirals | A | 9 | Stephen Duncan '16 | | Shiv Saini '16 | |
| B | 5 | Carson Collier '16 | | Aidan Morgan '17 | |
| South River High School | Varsity | A | 4 | Leo Boucher '18 | | | |
| B | 11 | | | Ethan Schrand '19 | |
| Southern Regional High School | Rams | A | 11 | Emily Haig '17 | | Sam Westby '16 | 1-2 |
| | Michael Scales '16 | 3-8 |
| B | 7 | Dana Haig '18 | 1-3,6-8 | Jake Ellis '15 | 1-3,6-8 |
| Jake Ellis '15 | 4-5 | Dana Haig '18 | 4-5 |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers | A | 13 | Thomas Quinn '18 | | Gal Behiri '15 | |
| B | 14 | KK Newsham '15 | 1-3 | Juliana Rustum '16 | |
| Danny Kane '16 | 4-8 | | |
| Toms River North | Mariners | A | 3 | Sean Crabb '16 | | Eddie Harrison '18 | |
| B | 9 | James Koerner '17 | | Mia Porter '18 | |
| Toms River South | Indians | A | 7 | Matt Roleke '15 | | Lauren Zelenak '17 | |
| B | 12 | Katie Oksen '15 | 1-4,7-8 | Willow Wahlers '17 | |
| Joey Cashman '18 | 5-6 | | |
