| Christian Brothers Academy | Colts 1 | A | 5 | Christopher Small '26 | | Nicholas Cunha '23 | |
| B | 2 | Bryce Vitiello '23 | | Luke Pennisi '24 | |
| Christian Brothers Academy | Colts 2 | A | 10 | Noah Kuzloski '23 | | Jules Buczkowski '26 | |
| B | 3 | Mitchell Hnatt '24 | | Kyle Lombardino '25 | |
| Delbarton School | Green Wave | A | 1 | James O'Gwen '23 | | Johnny Lang '23 | |
| B | 15 | Jack Tonzola '25 | | Colin Pryma '24 | |
| Donovan Catholic High School | Griffins | A | 8 | James Kopack '24 | | Caroline Felser '24 | |
| B | 4 | Kevin Brooksbank '23 | | Liam Marcell '26 | |
| Mamaroneck High School | Tigers | A | 9 | Gabby Collins '24 | | Carlo Osuna '25 | |
| B | 5 | Michelle Kaneti '25 | 1-4 | Jonathan Wittick '25 | 1-3 |
| Jonathan Wittick '25 | 5-6 | Graham Welsh '23 | 4-6 |
| Point Pleasant Beach High School | Garnett Gulls | A | 7 | Richard Pokorny '25 | | Logan Batyr '25 | |
| B | 14 | Sydney Mihalko '25 | | Hudson DePaul '26 | |
| Ranney School | Panthers | A | 13 | Grace Bray '23 | | Sophia Behar '25 | 1-4 |
| | Anthony Abboud '25 | 5-6 |
| B | 6 | Jack Whitman '23 | 1-4 | Tomas Mora '23 | |
| Lewis Forrest '25 | 5-6 | | |
| Rye Country Day School | Wildcats | A | 14 | Connor Davidson '24 | 1-2,5-6 | Ade Larsen '23 | 1-2,5-6 |
| Alice Rikkers '26 | 3-4 | Sara Komaroff '27 | 3-4 |
| B | 10 | Connor Rusch '25 | 1-4 | Josh Greene '25 | 1-2 |
| Hayden Hart '25 | 5-6 | Sam Sah-Nixon '25 | 3-4 |
| | Kyle Sisitsky '25 | 5-6 |
| Reserves | Stella Meymin '24Luke Sullivan '23 |
| Rye High School | Garnets | A | 11 | Saffer Lillian '23 | | Hugo Sacristan '26 | |
| B | 11 | Helen Halvorson '26 | | Finn Palermo '24 | |
| Seton Hall Preparatory School | Pirates | A | 2 | Drew D'Orsi '24 | | Arthur Fok '24 | |
| B | 8 | Ryan D'Orsi '26 | | Kyle Phillips '25 | |
| Southern Regional High School | Rams | A | 3 | Turner Ryon '25 | | Natalie Shaw '23 | 1-2 |
| | Noah Tallman '25 | 3-6 |
| B | 7 | Belle Placa '25 | | Erin Little '24 | |
| The Stony Brook School | Bears | A | 4 | Gavin Hudson '24 | | Mairead Reitzel '24 | 1-2,5-6 |
| | Amy Li '23 | 3-4 |
| B | 1 | Mauro Gonzales '24 | | Sean Beaver '23 | 1-4 |
| | Amy Li '23 | 5-6 |
| Reserves | JP Bennet '23Joshua Henson '25Jeremy Lunati '23 |
| Toms River North | Mariners | A | 12 | Iliana Vasslides '23 | 1-6 | Gabriel Vasslides '26 | 1-6 |
| B | 9 | Jackson Bubnowski '26 | 1-6 | Scott Tedeschi '25 | 1-6 |
| Toms River South | Indians | A | 6 | Ella Demand '24 | | Ava McNabb '24 | |
| B | 12 | Cali Krean '24 | | Chase Kalwinsky '26 | |
| Trinity Hall | Monarchs | A | 15 | Caroline Duffy '25 | 1-2,5-6 | Vanessa McCartin '26 | |
| Greta Senft '24 | 3-4 | | |
| B | 13 | Allison Beisel '24 | 1-2,5-6 | Colleen Yurcisin '23 * | 1-2,5-6 |
| Riley Mueller '27 | 3-4 | Evelyn Magee '26 | 3-4 |
